I took a look at these proposals and actually the crater one has more potential than the other. I have made some comments (in red) on both proposals within the body of the proposal as well as some general comments at the end. Both groups would need to make some adjustments to their proposals in order to be able to target. The Channel group has a way to go, though its doable if they do make some adjustments. The Moon group will need to specify where they will get their Moon data, as well as make some adjustments to their question as well. The crater group at least has some information that ties together their proposal. The channel group is very disconnected. Both groups biggest weakness is the fact that they want to do a scientific study with 1 piece (or very few pieces) of data. Answering a question using 1 THEMIS images is IMPOSSIBLE!!!
This means ypou won't have time to target and get the images back in time for the fair. Your only hope now is to work with existing images.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment